Sunday, July 22, 2012
Thursday, July 19, 2012
Let's All Write a Calligram
The Calligram, as Ron Padgett explains in our text The Teacher and Writer's Handbook of Poetic Forms (for newcomers, I am attempting to write one poem in every form covered in the book), is a form named after the Greek terms for "beautiful writing." The form is to make a poem in which the words form a picture. By way of example, Guillaume Apollinaire was, perhaps, one of the most famous poets to employ this form. Here is an example of one of his poems:
The poem is shaped like the Eiffel Tower, you see.
And so, approaching this form, I thought about images that I could form into, especially images which I might be interested in composing a poem on. My first thought was to make a poem in the shape of my dog Schubert, but when I latched onto that idea I found that I kept putting off writing the thing. Upon examination I found that I feared that such a poem would be too folksy, too close to cowboy poetry (a form which is mercifully absent from this text and which I would likely scrap this project if compelled to attempt to ever write one).
Then I had a panic attack earlier today. Or something like that. Anyway, my mind was running in circles of fear and I was on the phone with Laurie at lunch trying to talk my way out of it. That seems to help me sometimes. After I got off the phone, I remembered that wonderful quote by author Neil Gaiman:
The poem is shaped like the Eiffel Tower, you see.
And so, approaching this form, I thought about images that I could form into, especially images which I might be interested in composing a poem on. My first thought was to make a poem in the shape of my dog Schubert, but when I latched onto that idea I found that I kept putting off writing the thing. Upon examination I found that I feared that such a poem would be too folksy, too close to cowboy poetry (a form which is mercifully absent from this text and which I would likely scrap this project if compelled to attempt to ever write one).
Then I had a panic attack earlier today. Or something like that. Anyway, my mind was running in circles of fear and I was on the phone with Laurie at lunch trying to talk my way out of it. That seems to help me sometimes. After I got off the phone, I remembered that wonderful quote by author Neil Gaiman:
“Remember, whatever discipline you’re in, whether you’re a musician or a photographer, a fine artist or a cartoonist, a writer, a dancer, a singer, a designer — whatever you do, you have one thing that’s unique: You have the ability to make art. And for me, and for so many of the people I’ve known, that’s been a lifesaver, the ultimate lifesaver. It gets you through good times, and it gets you through … the other ones. Sometimes life is hard. Things go wrong — in life and in love and in business and in friendship and in health and in all the other ways life can go wrong. And when things get tough, this is what you should do: Make good art. I’m serious. Husband runs off with a politician? Make good art. Leg crushed and then eaten by mutated boa constrictor? Make good art. IRS on your trail? Make good art. Cat exploded? Make good art. Someone on the Internet thinks what you’re doing is stupid or evil or it’s all been done before? Make good art. Probably things will work out somehow, eventually time will take the sting away, and that doesn’t even matter. Do what only you can do best: Make good art. Make it on the bad days, make it on the good days, too.”And so I went more abstract and made my calligram of my panic attack. I call it A) Lopressor, B) Metformin, or C) Ativan? You will probably need to click on the image in order to make it large enough for you to read it.
Sunday, July 15, 2012
Saturday, July 14, 2012
Introducing Quixote
![]() | ||
| "You're reading them out of order now?!!? Outrageous! 10 points from Ravenclaw!" |
As a little glimpse inside my brain, I can tell you that I struggled for some time over feeling guilty about this.
I decided to go with the recent Edith Grossman translation. Quixote is one of those books that, as I have often heard from trusted sources, has suffered much in translation. One of the key concerns seems to be preservation of tone and, specifically, humor. I had heard good things about the Raffel translation as well, but my tipping point was in the footnotes and in the recommendation of the Grossman by my friend Christopher. I am well into the text and feel that this was the best possible choice. It really is, as the endorsement by Library Journal claims on the cover, "the translation to beat."
The translators preface further serves to back up what I assume was Ms. Grossman's intentions/philosophy in her translation. Simply put, she intends to preserve the experience that readers of the work in Spanish would have for readers of the work in English. She writes, "...all human efforts to communicate- even in the same language- are equally utopian, equally luminous with value, and equally worth the doing."
I skipped most of Harold Bloom's introduction. Look, I have enjoyed Professor Bloom's work in the past and I am sure I will again in the future. I did not enjoy his introduction at this particular time. He spends a great deal of the introduction comparing Cervantes to Shakespeare (who, granted, were contemporaries to the point where they actually died on the same day.) I commented to Laurie that it struck me as being a bit like what Quentin Crisp said about television interviews:
A television interview, you see, is like a geography examination. You can’t study the whole world. Therefore, on the night before your exam, you take your atlas down from its shelf and open it at random. The map that you happen to expose is of China. You regard this as a sign from You-Know-Who and study China. The next day the main question in your paper is about France. You-Know-Who has sold you a pup. Don’t panic. Your answer begins, "France is not like China, which is . . . "I haven't graphed it, but I suspect he spent more of his introduction talking about Shakespeare than Cervantes.
But that is not why I skipped it. I skipped it because twice in the few pages I read, Professor Bloom committed the unforgivable sin of revealing major plot points of the work that I was about to read. I am cursed with the sort of brain that remembers everything. I don't care how famous you believe the work to be, if you are called upon to speak before a piece, it is part of your duty to preserve the wonderful experience before all of the audience, especially those who have never had the pleasure before. If you are unable to do this, you should not be speaking in that context. In fact, I would suggest to the publisher that what they have from Professor Bloom is not an Introduction that should ever be used for this piece. What they have from Professor Bloom is probably an excellent Afterword. I shall treat it as such and I shall return to comment on it once I've finished the book.
And then there is Cervantes' own Prologue. I was instantly enchanted. I literally smiled while I was reading it. I am finding Cervantes to be delightful clever, but that is an terrible understatement. I am finding Cervantes to be one of the cleverest authors I have ever had the pleasure to read. In his prologue he establishes that we are to read a work of satire and that the target of the satire will largely be chivalry (although there seems to be a winking understanding that the scope of the work shall be far far larger.) He also establishes the startling modernity of the work. Having read Milton and Shakespeare in recent memory, I found it astoundingly modern to be reading not only a novel, but one in which the author periodically appears in the narrative.
In short, I have no regrets over my decision.
Wednesday, July 11, 2012
Plutarch's Lives- Part 4: Ceasar and Antony
Julius Caesar bestrode this narrow world like a colossus. He stomped on the Terra. We of the Judeo-Christian worldview like to think that we have the market cornered on events from 2000ish years ago which still impact every living human today, but, with all due respect, there was a secular moment of at least equal secular importance when a group of men walked into the Roman senate and stabbed the reigning dictator for life to death.
The sheer force of nature that was Julius Caesar is abundantly clear in the unfolding of his story. Even saying any of this reminds me of how odd I've found the endorsement blurbs on the copy of Don Quixote that I'm about to read. And, no, they are not just endorsing the translation.
"Yes, even some people of our own time love the best thing ever." -Paul MathersEven down to the New York Times Bestseller label on the cover. I wonder if there is an edition of the Bible that boasts New York Times Bestseller.
What's so great about Julius Caesar? Well, the first answer is that Plutarch clearly feels that Julius Caesar was the zenith of nobility towards which one ought to aspire. The dizzying heights of his elevation certainly must have a dash of the hyperbolic about it, although I feel so horribly tainted by the modern anti-civilization mindset when I say that.
Certainly the conquest of Gaul is one of his inspiring achievements and students of Latin will more likely than not be called upon to read Caesar's own account of the campaign at some point in their studies. There is also the weighty Roman Civil War circling around the power shift between Pompey and Julius. Ascending to power, he took on the mantle of Dictator for Life. Several of those close to him conspired to make that a much shorter honorific than it might initially sound.
Aside from these achievements, the man is portrayed as a model of virtue. He overcomes extreme odds (just think of it: a warrior with epilepsy) by the force of a gargantuan will which would come to be envied by the likes of Nietzsche and Wagner. Indeed, I felt there was something almost American in the individual will to power of Julius Caesar. You can take that statement any way you like. In a lot of ways, his is a snowball that is still rolling and gaining mass, for better or worse.
Having intimated that last point twice already in this post, my internal professor is rabid to write in the margins in red ink "Give Examples!"
1. Caesars were not Caesars until Julius Caesar. He, in fact, changed government forever.
2. As I mentioned, his writings are standard for Latin students, making him one of the key figures in one of the major roots from which the English language grows. And I think we can all agree that language has a direct effect upon reality; if not one of its major shapers, certainly, as Wittgenstein said, the fence at the limit of reality.
3. His story is woven into the fabric of our reality as well. He came, he saw, he conquered. "The die is cast" (I can't tell you how often I think that in the course of my daily life.) The Ides of March and "Et tu, Brute?" He is in Dante's Limbo and the subject of one of the greatest plays in the English language (two if you count Shaw. And I do.)
Again, even listing these things makes me feel like I am giving an endorsement to something far greater than I.
Plutarch doesn't bother to include a summation comparing Caesar to Antony, at least not in this edition, and I have to assume that the truths were suspected, rightly I should think, to be self-evident.
Antony is described as dissolute. He gambles; he drinks; he sleeps around; he is a member of some weird cult that goes around whacking women with whips on Lupercalia. On that note, I felt there was a bit of a microcosm of the whole dynamic of the two men in the famous story where Antony approaches Caesar on Lupercalia with a crown, which Caesar declines in a gentlemanly manner to the great joy and support of the crowd. I found Antony to be, in stark contrast to Caesar, one who was being chewed up in the teeth of time, rather than the chewer. Another microcosm might be in each man's story of their relationship with their lover in common, that is to say Cleopatra. Caesar restores her to her throne, effectively increasing both of their power (if not adding a bit more straw to the camel's back of those who were plotting his death.) Antony follows her around like a puppy, which eventually leads him to the end of his own sword.
One difference in these two sections from any of the others is that they both contained stories of other major figures. Cleopatra probably receives the most coverage. She ascends to power, much like Caesar by willpower and manipulating circumstances to her advantage. In fact, her suicide is one of those rare suicides that seems like an act born from a place of power. She escapes her prison by the only means available to her. She also has the ingenuity of gruesome foresight. The painting at the beginning of this post is of Cleopatra testing poisons on condemned prisoners to see which one she might like best when the time comes to commit self-slaughter.
Timon of Athens is introduced as one of the most famous misanthropes of antiquity. But for me the portion with the most emotional impact was the section about Caesar's murderers. I was mainly struck by how much that section read like a prose retelling of the plot of Shakespeare's tragedy on the subject (not being an idiot, I know full well that the opposite is, in fact, the case.) I was most stunned by the moments after his murder. Of course, there were no police to be called. The murderers walked out of there expecting change, solidarity, a new order. Instead, people are stunned and then, after Antony's stirring speech, outraged.
I think the key lesson I gleaned from this section was to wield the power one has been granted for good and to build. The negative example is one against allowing one's self to be blown about by circumstance or to allow one's self to commit wicked acts for the promise of better circumstances.
Sunday, July 8, 2012
Paul Mathers Makes Pacifists Fight
I can't believe I did this. You won't believe it either! This week's topic was a dash on the jocular side.
Saturday, July 7, 2012
Plutarch's Lives- Part 3: Demosthenes and Cicero
Cicero and Demosthenes were both orators of great acclaim in their respective places. Demosthenes had to work for his oration skill and in that sense reminded me a bit of Milton. He expended a great deal of time and energy on honing his skill, then reaped the benefit (sort of... for a time anyway.) He was occasionally mocked for his practiced orations, but it seems no one took such criticisms seriously in light of the man's oratory skill. He, perhaps ill advisedly, entered politics, which ultimately lead to drinking poison to avoid falling into the hands of his enemies.
I have noticed Plutarch seeming to show marked favoritism towards the Roman figures. I may be reading too much into this (or it may simply be a result of the choices in this abridgment) and it may have more to do with Plutarch's familiarity and the availability of information to him, but it really does seem to me that the Roman pieces are far more compelling and perhaps a bit more on the noble side.
The story of Cicero was a bit more engaging, especially since it is building to the end of the reading in Plutarch. The book ends with Caesar and Antony. There is overlap with Cicero's story in each of those.
Cicero's death was absolutely grizzly. Something about cutting off someone's hands and head and then traveling with them to a place where they are to be put on spikes doesn't sit well with me. I know that Julius Caesar is said to have remarked, ominously, that the best sort of death is a sudden one. I'm not sure I agree with that. Dying at the violent hands of others seems terrible to me. I imagine my final thought would be something like "I never made it through Infinite Jest!" What a horrible way to go! I increasingly find myself feeling that a good death is a lingering one, like Mozart who laid on his deathbed composing his Requiem (apocryphally it seems, but it makes a nice story, what?)
It would be difficult for me to not love Cicero. He was a bit of a rascal and his wit was enviably keen. The accounts seem to suggest a decent and lovable man, but he had this knack for boasting and self-promoting that put me in mind of a modern day rapper.
Rather than rehashing the details of their lives, I should, as Plutarch intended in writing these lives in the first place, focus on what lessons I gleaned from reading about these two men. I think that Plutarch would agree that looking at the lives of the great people of history can and should inspire the reader and instruct them in good living, be it in the positive or negative example (with the added level of whether or not the reader agrees with the author's point of view.) I would add, and I also think Plutarch and Dr. Eliot would back me up on this, that this is precisely why a work like this ought to be requisite to the education of young people. Perhaps this might serve as a drop of antidote in the ocean of arrested adolescence which comprises the culture in which they bob rudderless (there I go mixing metaphors again. Oh well. I've buttered my bread and now I must lay in it.) Aside from the historic material from, what one could certainly argue if one were so inclined, two of the most important civilizations of all time, one gets the distinct impression that the true function of the book is examples of great men towards which one can aspire. I found the lives of these two men to be an inspiration to strive towards excellence.
There was also, I felt, a theme emerging which I know will be a through-line in the remainder of my reading: beware of the shifting sands of politics. Both men are essentially destroyed by the capricious nature of the divine right of kings, which seems to have been especially capricious in times of capricious divinity. That may sound like a dig against antiquity, but I will reveal my opinion that I feel much the same way about the prevailing directions of religious devotion in my own time and country.
Both men shared the experience of aligning themselves with a political position that eventually led to their respective deaths. I suppose this could be taken in a number of ways. I could see this suggesting the path of political forbearance. I could also see this suggesting the nobility of staying true to one's cause even unto death. Not knowing any political leaders personally and having zero interest in politics, my interest in this thought experiment seemed theoretical on the surface. But I think that these lessons transfer on a micro-scale. Politics touch all of our interpersonal interactions, be it in our workplace, our churches, or even our homes. I am not talking exclusively about political ideology, but also about the teetering balances of power found anywhere power is available. I think one of the major lessons from the lives of the noble ancients is to let truth and virtue be your leader and even if you find yourself on the business end of a vial of poison, you will be exactly where you are supposed to be.
Wednesday, July 4, 2012
Let's All Write Bouts-rimés: Poem the Final- Judy
Way back before the Pleistocene Epoch, back in the haziest mists of time, I started a project where I would work through Ron Padgett's book A Handbook of Poetic Forms. The project was to write a poem for every form represented in the text. I got through the end of the letter 'B.'
To be fair, I never willfully stopped doing the project and, therefore, in my own mind was still doing the project. However, I think it was about a year ago when I first mentioned the Bouts-rimés topic. I received a great deal of response from people who wanted me to write a poem using their list of rhyming words and, being a softie, I chose to attempt to write one for everyone who participated. Then, time continued to march on. I wrote a few and, a few months later, wrote a few more. And then...
So, I intended to write the remaining poems and then continue the project, but found that one of the remaining two (I think) has disappeared. I knew the book in which I had placed the list, but it was no longer in that book. That was my friend Kari's list of suggestions. I apologize, but we are moving on. If I find that list in the future, I will write the poem and post it, but for now I have written a poem for Judy's list. After this, we move on to other forms.
For some reason, I kept thinking of Flashman when meditating on these sets of rhymes and decided to pick the narrative voice of a man fleeing from serving his country in battle.
Called from the comfort of my duvet
to Her Majesty's service in parts near Bombay.
Patriotic sentiment precludes a "no way."
I packed my essentials and fled in dismay
with a rucksack of Talisker and set for croquet.
Took discretion for valor, then took the highway
in hopes from my duty that road would convey
my heart and my hind where they might be okay
lest on some far battleground they should decay.
My hope for a future rose like a soufflé.
All duty to country I felt I've prepaid
by ensuring my life for a henceforth of todays.
Laying low, unobserved, on outlaying roadways,
I'd be better employed sniffing future bouquets.
To be fair, I never willfully stopped doing the project and, therefore, in my own mind was still doing the project. However, I think it was about a year ago when I first mentioned the Bouts-rimés topic. I received a great deal of response from people who wanted me to write a poem using their list of rhyming words and, being a softie, I chose to attempt to write one for everyone who participated. Then, time continued to march on. I wrote a few and, a few months later, wrote a few more. And then...
So, I intended to write the remaining poems and then continue the project, but found that one of the remaining two (I think) has disappeared. I knew the book in which I had placed the list, but it was no longer in that book. That was my friend Kari's list of suggestions. I apologize, but we are moving on. If I find that list in the future, I will write the poem and post it, but for now I have written a poem for Judy's list. After this, we move on to other forms.
For some reason, I kept thinking of Flashman when meditating on these sets of rhymes and decided to pick the narrative voice of a man fleeing from serving his country in battle.
Called from the comfort of my duvet
to Her Majesty's service in parts near Bombay.
Patriotic sentiment precludes a "no way."
I packed my essentials and fled in dismay
with a rucksack of Talisker and set for croquet.
Took discretion for valor, then took the highway
in hopes from my duty that road would convey
my heart and my hind where they might be okay
lest on some far battleground they should decay.
My hope for a future rose like a soufflé.
All duty to country I felt I've prepaid
by ensuring my life for a henceforth of todays.
Laying low, unobserved, on outlaying roadways,
I'd be better employed sniffing future bouquets.
Sunday, July 1, 2012
Paul Mathers on Ray Bradbury
Once a week, I pull a topic that someone has sent me out of a hat at random. I then make a video of me speaking on that topic. This week's topic: Ray Bradbury's Relevance Today:
Saturday, June 30, 2012
Plutarch's Lives part 2: Alcibiades and Coriolanus
![]() |
| Socrates finds Alcibiades. Being a wise man, he knew where to look. |
We seem to have turned a corner fairly quickly and my initial reactions may only apply to the initial material. The two sections that I have just completed were a rip-roaring good read. We also seem to have entered the portion in which the parallel lives is fleshed out a bit more fully by the author, even so far as to include a sum up in which he states what specific parallels he is intending to illustrate with these lives. The two lives are interesting, explained to the reader with clarity, and I did not come away feeling that the comparison was in any way forced.
The thrust of the comparison, as I understood it, is as follows: Alcibiades and Coriolanus were successful in battle on more or less an equal level. They both had equal reasons to be loved by their societies on that level. In politics and personal lives, Alcibiades was dissolute and luxurious. He was unscrupulous and false. He caused a great deal of trouble and discord. He was, however, charismatic and, therefore, got away with it. Coriolanus', as the author puts it, "pride and self-will, the consort, as Plato calls it, of solitude, made him insufferable."
I found that I could relate to both and thus benefited from their cautionary tales. Alcibiades, with his bravado, his chameleon nature to circumstance, his flamboyance and tendency towards hedonism, all remind me of the younger version of myself. Coriolanus' insouciance towards public opinion (while aligning himself with extraordinarily unpopular opinion), or, it would seem, any form of compassion left him... well, dead eventually, but strongly and widely disliked.
While I am not like Coriolanus in his anti-social behavior, this speaks to the introvert's dilemma. I certainly have a great deal of compassion, but I find that I am one of those who needs a greater amount of time alone for every amount of time I spend with people, in order to "recharge" as it were. I am also disinclined to be in or near a crowd (defined as more than 3 people) and tend to be too heavy in lighter social situations. While Plutarch doesn't go so far as to lay out a system like Dale Carnegie, his underlying suggestion seems to be "make a little effort here, people." I felt like this is a lesson in particular that could use a bit of reviving in this age where everyone behaves as both a monarch and an island, answerable to none.
Likewise, the lesson of Alcibiades seems to be that one ought to exhibit a modicum of restraint in regards to self-indulgence. One ought to have a consistent character rather than flattering and manipulating to get one's way. This, too, I feel is an important lesson for today. At first, I thought I would be writing about striking a balance in one's life and behavior in regards to the two extremes presented in these two lives, however, upon reflection, I am finding that Plutarch is simply showing two sides of the same coin. Both are men whose self-interest precluded compassion.
I would add that Plutarch succeeds in communicating the tone of these lives in the reaction he seeks to elicit from the reader. I found myself charmed by Alcibiades in spite of the dastardly actions he is frequently described as undertaking, and found myself strongly disliking Coriolanus. As it said at the end of Barry Lyndon "They are all equal now."
It seems to be smooth sailing from here on. I have two great orators next and then two of the most famous leaders of antiquity.
Sunday, June 24, 2012
Paul Mathers on Reality Television
For more on my point of view, download and listen to this speech: http://www.learnoutloud.com/Free-Audio-Video/Arts-and-Entertainment/Film_-Music_-Radio_-TV_-and-Pop-Culture/Newton-Minow--Television-is-a-Vast-Wasteland/24098
Saturday, June 23, 2012
Plutarch's Lives- Part 1
The waggish part of my brain wonders if St. Augustine wasn't included in this series for the sole purpose of making future difficult reads seem more palatable.
Before I started reading Plutarch's Lives of the Noble Greeks and Romans, I pulled a small mass-market paperback copy from my personal library. I try to get my own copies of the books in this series because not underlining or writing in the margins is, to me, a bit like trying to read in a straightjacket. However, when I perused the table of contents of the actual Harvard Classics edition in the Chico Library, I distinctly remembered Demosthenes being a figure covered in the book (it stuck in my brain because of the joke commonly attributed to Alexander Woollcott "Demosthenes can do is bend and hold the legs together.") It turned out that my yellowed and foxing Dell Laurel edition was an abridgment. Hastened I to the used bookstore where I found this Modern Library edition:
You will note the "Volume 1" on the cover. I instantly noted that the volume was about twice as long as the Harvard Classics version and knew in my heart that our good captain Dr. Eliot has made his own abridgment (from the Dryden for those who care.) Back I went to the Chico Library.
The main issue with this book, at least so far in my reading, is that Plutarch does not write biography in the manner to which we have grown accustomed. This presents the reader with the challenge of modifying one's expectations. It also called for frequent visits to other sources to fill in information that the author presumes upon the reader. For several of the subjects I came to the text with some knowledge of their lives (Pericles, Coriolanus, Cicero, Caesar, Antony), which seems to aid comprehension of the author's intent when, say, discussing a conflict between two specific individuals without explaining who these two individuals are. Perhaps an example might illuminate what I'm on about. Here is a line from the opening paragraph of the book, in the section about Themistocles, specifically referring to his mother:
This would be an exercise in frustration were it not for the fact that Plutarch's purpose is not that of a historian or a biographer. His purpose is that of a moralist and he is employing (or, for the cynical, exploiting) the lives of the noble ancients for the purpose of illustrating traits that the author feels one ought to either emulate or eschew.
My first section comprises Themistocles, Pericles, and Aristides. There is a great deal of battle in these lives which, to me, is only slightly more interesting than sports writing. I have spent most of my time of reading this book trying to discern what lessons I might glean and, to be perfectly frank, disregarding the rest. Of the three, the latter was my favorite, likely because one of the chief lessons was nobility in poverty. Themistocles is sort of a cautionary tale. He is lauded after great success in battle, but later ostracized over unpopular political decisions, and then re-lauded after his death.
While I appreciated the section on Aristides, the section on Pericles was the section I found most gripping so far. Pericles is a great man, ruling in the Golden Age of Athens. Socrates makes a few appearances. There is political maneuvering against Cimon. There are mystical visions. There is, of course, one of the most famous wars in history, The Peloponnesian. There is even the suggestion of a love story/scandal with the fascinating character of Aspasia (I am amazed that no one has written a play or novel about that woman!) There is even more coloring of character than in the other sections so far (for example, apparently the man had a very large head.)
With eight more sections to go, I am out of the least familiar territory historically speaking. But I do have a bit of that feeling I have about an hour and a half into Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg when I am enjoying it tremendously to be sure, but I also know that it is miles to go before I sleep.
Before I started reading Plutarch's Lives of the Noble Greeks and Romans, I pulled a small mass-market paperback copy from my personal library. I try to get my own copies of the books in this series because not underlining or writing in the margins is, to me, a bit like trying to read in a straightjacket. However, when I perused the table of contents of the actual Harvard Classics edition in the Chico Library, I distinctly remembered Demosthenes being a figure covered in the book (it stuck in my brain because of the joke commonly attributed to Alexander Woollcott "Demosthenes can do is bend and hold the legs together.") It turned out that my yellowed and foxing Dell Laurel edition was an abridgment. Hastened I to the used bookstore where I found this Modern Library edition:
You will note the "Volume 1" on the cover. I instantly noted that the volume was about twice as long as the Harvard Classics version and knew in my heart that our good captain Dr. Eliot has made his own abridgment (from the Dryden for those who care.) Back I went to the Chico Library.
The main issue with this book, at least so far in my reading, is that Plutarch does not write biography in the manner to which we have grown accustomed. This presents the reader with the challenge of modifying one's expectations. It also called for frequent visits to other sources to fill in information that the author presumes upon the reader. For several of the subjects I came to the text with some knowledge of their lives (Pericles, Coriolanus, Cicero, Caesar, Antony), which seems to aid comprehension of the author's intent when, say, discussing a conflict between two specific individuals without explaining who these two individuals are. Perhaps an example might illuminate what I'm on about. Here is a line from the opening paragraph of the book, in the section about Themistocles, specifically referring to his mother:
"Yet Phanias writes that the mother of Themistocles was not of Thrace, but of Caria, and that her name was not Abrotonon, but Euterpe; and Neanthes adds farther that she was of Halicarnassus in Caria."Who were Phanias and Neanthes? What is the significance of the different names attributed to his mother? What would it suggest if one was from Thrace or Caria or Halicarnassus? Is this like saying "the musician claims to have grown up on the streets of Compton, but records show that he was president of the chess club at the Palos Verdes Preparatory School"? We don't know! At least not specifically from the text.
This would be an exercise in frustration were it not for the fact that Plutarch's purpose is not that of a historian or a biographer. His purpose is that of a moralist and he is employing (or, for the cynical, exploiting) the lives of the noble ancients for the purpose of illustrating traits that the author feels one ought to either emulate or eschew.
My first section comprises Themistocles, Pericles, and Aristides. There is a great deal of battle in these lives which, to me, is only slightly more interesting than sports writing. I have spent most of my time of reading this book trying to discern what lessons I might glean and, to be perfectly frank, disregarding the rest. Of the three, the latter was my favorite, likely because one of the chief lessons was nobility in poverty. Themistocles is sort of a cautionary tale. He is lauded after great success in battle, but later ostracized over unpopular political decisions, and then re-lauded after his death.
While I appreciated the section on Aristides, the section on Pericles was the section I found most gripping so far. Pericles is a great man, ruling in the Golden Age of Athens. Socrates makes a few appearances. There is political maneuvering against Cimon. There are mystical visions. There is, of course, one of the most famous wars in history, The Peloponnesian. There is even the suggestion of a love story/scandal with the fascinating character of Aspasia (I am amazed that no one has written a play or novel about that woman!) There is even more coloring of character than in the other sections so far (for example, apparently the man had a very large head.)
With eight more sections to go, I am out of the least familiar territory historically speaking. But I do have a bit of that feeling I have about an hour and a half into Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg when I am enjoying it tremendously to be sure, but I also know that it is miles to go before I sleep.
Friday, June 8, 2012
Evolutionary Coda
I was sitting there on my lunch break the other day when a man, a complete stranger to me, approached on a bicycle. He was around retirement age and the repair and accessories of his bicycle as well as his dress suggested a man of modest means and likely a more solitary existence, but not an unpleasant sort of person.
As for me, my moment before the encounter was spent realizing that I had 10 more minutes of my lunch break and only 3 more pages left before I completed the chapter I was reading. I was inclined towards finishing the chapter before I had to return from my break.
The man said, "How's the reading?"
I said, "Great as always."
He said, "What are you reading?"
I said, "Mr. Charles Darwin."
He screeched to a halt. I think he actually said, "Uh oh." I knew exactly what was going through his head and what was about to happen. The man, in his head, thought that this was the moment where he meets the secular humanist on the road and evangelizes him, or at least does intellectual battle with him. What went on in my head was, "Great. Now I'm going to have to listen to this guy and not get to finish my chapter."
It was a source of great amazement to me how reading Darwin in public inspires more strangers to feel compelled to talk to you about religion than does reading the Bible in public.
I felt a little cheap after I thought, "This guy is looking for a great story to tell his church group. He wants to tell the story of the atheist he met on the path and either he stood his ground for the truth of the Gospel or, even better, he preached at the atheist until the atheist got down on his knees a-weeping and repenting." Immediately followed by the humbling thought, "Wait a minute, Paul. Aren't you already planning to use this story on your blog?"
I did not say much. I mainly didn't say much because he didn't ask much. He lectured and I silently prayed, "God help him if he ever meets the person he currently thinks he is meeting. He'll be eaten alive." He began to speak in such a way that I could not break out of the conversation without compromising my standing as a gentleman. I felt a little like I did when Mormons came to my door the other day. I felt a little cheated because I would love to have an intelligent conversation about ideas, but that was not on the table here. What was on the table was for some guy I don't know to tell me what he thinks and then leave, feeling good about himself and feeling no requirement to give me another thought so long as he lives.
How did this come to be?
I also felt a little bad that he was not about to obtain the narrative from his encounter with me that he was expecting. He started out with the unsolicited advice that I should balance reading Darwin with also reading the New Testament. I said, "I fully anticipate that I shall" although, in all honesty, I am currently studying through the book of Ruth and, frankly, am not doing so to "balance" anything.
He asked me if I knew why there was so much evil in the world. I said, "Yes. Because of sin." And at that moment I had the distinct impression that he realized that he was not talking to "the enemy." He talked for a while about his view of science and religion and about how he lives in a low income apartment complex for the elderly and about the CMA church that he attends. I then got the sense that he didn't really have all that much interest in speaking to me as a fellow human being now that he felt to his satisfaction that I wasn't someone that he needed to correct and, just as he arrived, he left.
I had this moment as he started to ride away where I had a vision, a moment where my internal camera pulled away into the third person, and I saw this lonely old poor man on a bicycle, riding away from a neurotic middle-aged poor man in a path in a neighborhood where wealthier people dwell. Two infinitesimal growths on the thin layer of scum covering a small rock hurtling through a dark void. It's only by the grace of God that an asteroid doesn't slam into the Earth, or Mount Lassen erupts, or the poles shift, or the coming antibiotic resistant plague doesn't arrive to wipe us all out of our strutting and fretting existence. While both of us owe our lives to the myriad shoulders of ancestors on which we stand, neither of us are exactly the sort of mover and shaker whose bold personality is going to insure top-feeding for us and our kin.
And I called out after him, probably out of his range of hearing, "You know, both can be true."
Charles Darwin's On The Origin of Species- Part 3
“The finger of God never leaves identical fingerprints.” -Stanislaus Lec
I had intended to break this book into four blog entry responses, but enthusiasm got the better of me and I finished the whole thing over the past few days. So, this is the conclusion.
Darwin was wrong about one thing, although it was something that everyone was wrong about in his day and for a long time afterward. He spent a great deal of this section writing about geology and he has no concept of tectonic plates or of Pangea, a relatively new scientific understanding. (Fun fact: Did you know that one of the last things Albert Einstein ever wrote was the foreword to a book about the coming polar shifts? The major hypothesis of how it was to happen in that book relied on a pre-tectonic plate understanding of the Earth's crust.) Darwin then sets up and jumps through a lot of hoops in the latter half of the book to explain how different species came to be located in different places on the planet. This leads to what I found to be some of the more entertaining portions of the entire text.
Some of the sections that I found most interesting involved experiments that Darwin carried out to see how long diverse and sundry seeds could float in salt water and still germinate. He observes how many and often seeds are found stuck to the feet of birds. This suggests an extremely old Earth from the law of averages of how often seeds would stick to the feet of birds or float across the sea for us to find similar flora in different lands. He talks about a time on the Beagle when a bird blew onto their deck, confused and very far from home as he knew it to be a landlocked bird from far far away.
It is also important to mention his repeated referral to the imperfection of our geological record (and that the geological record is intermittent). He was correct. The geological record was imperfect and, as it fleshed out over the following 150 years, turned out to support his theory far more than he likely would even have imagined. At the end of the book (and I mean within the last 5 pages) he slips dangerously close to a polemic. He has a great deal to say to the special creation crowd, but he also reserves some fire for geologists, essentially haranguing them to get their act together.
There is also a section on hybridism. In one portion he talks about diversity strengthening species (as in diverse groups within the species procreating leading to stronger individuals). I hear that this was a special point of concern for Darwin as he worried that having married his first cousin might have been related to the poor health and early deaths of some of their own children.
The section on extinction was a bit archaic as well. At one point he writes "...the utter extinction of a group is generally, as we have seen, a slower process than its production." In the margin I wrote "Yeah, not so much anymore!" Which leads to a modern given that seems to have been entirely beyond the imagination of Mr. Darwin, that is to say the destructive capacity of humankind. To read this biologist writing in a time before one could even think that humankind has it within their grasp to kill every living thing on the planet reminds me of looking into the face of my grandchild and wondering what it was like to be unaware that one day you will die.
Darwin never gets to the "Monkeys is peoples" part. I am given to understand that one must needs read The Descent of Man for that little gem. He does suggest that the embryonic state of a species recalls the parent form, but that's as close as we get to all of the fuss. The Descent of Man is not included in the curriculum of this current reading project, but given how much I've enjoyed reading Darwin I fully expect to read it one day.
We do get this, "Whenever it is fully admitted, as I believe it will some day be, that each species has proceeded from a single birthplace, and when in the course of time we know something definite about the means of distribution, we shall be enabled to speculate with security on the former extension of the land." Rather, we grew to understand both more fully, but the "single birthplace" line has been a pebble in my shoe for the past few days.
I recommend reading Darwin. As I've said before, it is a piece that one must deal with one way or another at some point or another in life. You really ought to read what the man has to say for himself rather than taking it through the filter of others. Then and only then do you get to come over the grown ups table when you talk about these ideas. If you are a person of faith, let me, as a person of faith, assure you that there is no idea in this work that will shatter your faith. In fact, I would say that if there is an idea out there that will shatter your faith, you have a much bigger problem than that idea existing. It means that your faith is weak and shatter-able.
Although, even better, it is a fascinating book with so much to teach. Darwin is tremendously generous with his knowledge of the natural world and his ideas are well worth engaging with. As with so much of this series, I feel richer for the experience. You read to engage with ideas for yourself. If you don't want to engage with ideas, you are living incorrectly.
I had intended to break this book into four blog entry responses, but enthusiasm got the better of me and I finished the whole thing over the past few days. So, this is the conclusion.
Darwin was wrong about one thing, although it was something that everyone was wrong about in his day and for a long time afterward. He spent a great deal of this section writing about geology and he has no concept of tectonic plates or of Pangea, a relatively new scientific understanding. (Fun fact: Did you know that one of the last things Albert Einstein ever wrote was the foreword to a book about the coming polar shifts? The major hypothesis of how it was to happen in that book relied on a pre-tectonic plate understanding of the Earth's crust.) Darwin then sets up and jumps through a lot of hoops in the latter half of the book to explain how different species came to be located in different places on the planet. This leads to what I found to be some of the more entertaining portions of the entire text.
Some of the sections that I found most interesting involved experiments that Darwin carried out to see how long diverse and sundry seeds could float in salt water and still germinate. He observes how many and often seeds are found stuck to the feet of birds. This suggests an extremely old Earth from the law of averages of how often seeds would stick to the feet of birds or float across the sea for us to find similar flora in different lands. He talks about a time on the Beagle when a bird blew onto their deck, confused and very far from home as he knew it to be a landlocked bird from far far away.
It is also important to mention his repeated referral to the imperfection of our geological record (and that the geological record is intermittent). He was correct. The geological record was imperfect and, as it fleshed out over the following 150 years, turned out to support his theory far more than he likely would even have imagined. At the end of the book (and I mean within the last 5 pages) he slips dangerously close to a polemic. He has a great deal to say to the special creation crowd, but he also reserves some fire for geologists, essentially haranguing them to get their act together.
There is also a section on hybridism. In one portion he talks about diversity strengthening species (as in diverse groups within the species procreating leading to stronger individuals). I hear that this was a special point of concern for Darwin as he worried that having married his first cousin might have been related to the poor health and early deaths of some of their own children.
The section on extinction was a bit archaic as well. At one point he writes "...the utter extinction of a group is generally, as we have seen, a slower process than its production." In the margin I wrote "Yeah, not so much anymore!" Which leads to a modern given that seems to have been entirely beyond the imagination of Mr. Darwin, that is to say the destructive capacity of humankind. To read this biologist writing in a time before one could even think that humankind has it within their grasp to kill every living thing on the planet reminds me of looking into the face of my grandchild and wondering what it was like to be unaware that one day you will die.
Darwin never gets to the "Monkeys is peoples" part. I am given to understand that one must needs read The Descent of Man for that little gem. He does suggest that the embryonic state of a species recalls the parent form, but that's as close as we get to all of the fuss. The Descent of Man is not included in the curriculum of this current reading project, but given how much I've enjoyed reading Darwin I fully expect to read it one day.
We do get this, "Whenever it is fully admitted, as I believe it will some day be, that each species has proceeded from a single birthplace, and when in the course of time we know something definite about the means of distribution, we shall be enabled to speculate with security on the former extension of the land." Rather, we grew to understand both more fully, but the "single birthplace" line has been a pebble in my shoe for the past few days.
I recommend reading Darwin. As I've said before, it is a piece that one must deal with one way or another at some point or another in life. You really ought to read what the man has to say for himself rather than taking it through the filter of others. Then and only then do you get to come over the grown ups table when you talk about these ideas. If you are a person of faith, let me, as a person of faith, assure you that there is no idea in this work that will shatter your faith. In fact, I would say that if there is an idea out there that will shatter your faith, you have a much bigger problem than that idea existing. It means that your faith is weak and shatter-able.
Although, even better, it is a fascinating book with so much to teach. Darwin is tremendously generous with his knowledge of the natural world and his ideas are well worth engaging with. As with so much of this series, I feel richer for the experience. You read to engage with ideas for yourself. If you don't want to engage with ideas, you are living incorrectly.
Wednesday, June 6, 2012
Live Forever!
When I was in Junior High, we went to see Ray Bradbury speak at Chapman University. I employ no hyperbole in saying that this was one of the most important nights of my life.
At the time, I was just getting into my voracious reading habit. The event was around the release of his HIGHLY underrated book Green Shadows, White Whale. If you've never read it, you must. It's about when he was in Ireland writing the screenplay for the John Huston film adaptation of Moby Dick. It is a wonderful book and you should rush out and get it with all speed.
His speech was magical and, afterwards, I got to meet him. I had one of those star-struck moments where you start babbling incoherently. Bradbury was very gracious and encouraging, very kind. He understood being the awkward little geeky kid. As I learned, he spent much of his youth in Hollywood having similar experiences staking out in front of movie studios to get autographs.
He autographed our copy of Green Shadows, White Whale, my old mass-market paperback edition of The Machineries of Joy, and a copy of the photograph at the top of the page. We asked him what the cat was named and he wrote "Tigger!" next to the cat. I walked away mesmerized, as if I'd just met Twain or Hemingway, an American author of that caliber. Not just a great American author, but The great American author of his time. And, of course, I was correct.
I immediately read everything by him that I could get my hands on. I think Bradbury would have liked that the news of his death took me back to that time in my life where it seems like I spent all of my time in expensive bookstores at South Coast Plaza and in libraries (I almost didn't say the libraries part because it still seems like that's where I spend all of my time), when I could be so consumed by an author that I would read their entire bibliography without pause, without hardly even looking up from the text. Back in those days before the world became nothing more than germs trying to kill me and before I somehow got enmeshed in a religion that tries to heap shame on me for reading or listening to books or ideas that they don't specifically condone. Back before life beat the enthusiasm out of me. Today reminded me of a part of myself that is still in there deep down somewhere, like a dinosaur sleeping at the bottom of the ocean, waiting to be called back to the surface.
Ray Bradbury is a lot of why I am a pedestrian by nature. His short story The Pedestrian made a compelling and visceral argument for me about the narcotic culture in which we live. He has a lot to do with why I never watch the evening news willingly and when I am forced to for whatever reason it is all I can to do keep from throwing things at the screen. Later he reinforced this by pointing out the truth that all of these yip-dog political pundits who are flooding our airwaves and shanghai-ing our political discourse are destined to be forgotten before their bodies are even cold. Don't give the charlatans your press or your attention. He wrote me a permission slip to be an optimist in spite of it all. I wish I knew where I put that permission slip. I seem to have mislaid it somewhere along the way.
He was also the only grown-up I knew who confirmed what I knew: that my classmates were brutes and beasts.
He also showed me that it was okay to love without abandon, to go mad with enthusiasm, to cry like a volcano when occasion called for it. In his 1991 book of essays Yestermorrow, he inspired me through his reminiscences of his friendship with Renaissance scholar Bernard Berenson to stuff my eyes with great art in hopes that great art is what will come spilling back out of me. He told me to write constantly and to write about what grabs me. Also, no matter how old I get, I think I shall always be more than a little in love with the character of Clarisse McClellan from Fahrenheit 451.
On an individual level, I am sorry that he has died and I pray that his family can be comforted in this time of loss. If I could, I would offer that he seems to have lived about as rich, full, beautiful, and happy a life as a man can. His was a truly enviable life. As a human being, the sorrow goes far deeper in that the world is truly poorer for the loss of Ray Bradbury. He enriched humankind in more ways than I can reasonably list in a blog entry.
As for me, I only met the man that once. I am given to understand that the man had thousands of encounters like that. He was known for dazzling the enchanted kid at his book signings. My interactions were with the ideas that he published. I expect to read them to Ezekiel someday soon and I expect that, 500 years from now, Ezekiel's descendants will be reading Ray Bradbury to one another. As for me, the death of Ray Bradbury makes me want to be a better man, in hopes of preserving what would have otherwise been completely lost.
At the time, I was just getting into my voracious reading habit. The event was around the release of his HIGHLY underrated book Green Shadows, White Whale. If you've never read it, you must. It's about when he was in Ireland writing the screenplay for the John Huston film adaptation of Moby Dick. It is a wonderful book and you should rush out and get it with all speed.
His speech was magical and, afterwards, I got to meet him. I had one of those star-struck moments where you start babbling incoherently. Bradbury was very gracious and encouraging, very kind. He understood being the awkward little geeky kid. As I learned, he spent much of his youth in Hollywood having similar experiences staking out in front of movie studios to get autographs.
He autographed our copy of Green Shadows, White Whale, my old mass-market paperback edition of The Machineries of Joy, and a copy of the photograph at the top of the page. We asked him what the cat was named and he wrote "Tigger!" next to the cat. I walked away mesmerized, as if I'd just met Twain or Hemingway, an American author of that caliber. Not just a great American author, but The great American author of his time. And, of course, I was correct.
I immediately read everything by him that I could get my hands on. I think Bradbury would have liked that the news of his death took me back to that time in my life where it seems like I spent all of my time in expensive bookstores at South Coast Plaza and in libraries (I almost didn't say the libraries part because it still seems like that's where I spend all of my time), when I could be so consumed by an author that I would read their entire bibliography without pause, without hardly even looking up from the text. Back in those days before the world became nothing more than germs trying to kill me and before I somehow got enmeshed in a religion that tries to heap shame on me for reading or listening to books or ideas that they don't specifically condone. Back before life beat the enthusiasm out of me. Today reminded me of a part of myself that is still in there deep down somewhere, like a dinosaur sleeping at the bottom of the ocean, waiting to be called back to the surface.
Ray Bradbury is a lot of why I am a pedestrian by nature. His short story The Pedestrian made a compelling and visceral argument for me about the narcotic culture in which we live. He has a lot to do with why I never watch the evening news willingly and when I am forced to for whatever reason it is all I can to do keep from throwing things at the screen. Later he reinforced this by pointing out the truth that all of these yip-dog political pundits who are flooding our airwaves and shanghai-ing our political discourse are destined to be forgotten before their bodies are even cold. Don't give the charlatans your press or your attention. He wrote me a permission slip to be an optimist in spite of it all. I wish I knew where I put that permission slip. I seem to have mislaid it somewhere along the way.
He was also the only grown-up I knew who confirmed what I knew: that my classmates were brutes and beasts.
He also showed me that it was okay to love without abandon, to go mad with enthusiasm, to cry like a volcano when occasion called for it. In his 1991 book of essays Yestermorrow, he inspired me through his reminiscences of his friendship with Renaissance scholar Bernard Berenson to stuff my eyes with great art in hopes that great art is what will come spilling back out of me. He told me to write constantly and to write about what grabs me. Also, no matter how old I get, I think I shall always be more than a little in love with the character of Clarisse McClellan from Fahrenheit 451.
On an individual level, I am sorry that he has died and I pray that his family can be comforted in this time of loss. If I could, I would offer that he seems to have lived about as rich, full, beautiful, and happy a life as a man can. His was a truly enviable life. As a human being, the sorrow goes far deeper in that the world is truly poorer for the loss of Ray Bradbury. He enriched humankind in more ways than I can reasonably list in a blog entry.
As for me, I only met the man that once. I am given to understand that the man had thousands of encounters like that. He was known for dazzling the enchanted kid at his book signings. My interactions were with the ideas that he published. I expect to read them to Ezekiel someday soon and I expect that, 500 years from now, Ezekiel's descendants will be reading Ray Bradbury to one another. As for me, the death of Ray Bradbury makes me want to be a better man, in hopes of preserving what would have otherwise been completely lost.
Thursday, May 31, 2012
Charles Darwin's On The Origin of Species- Part 2
The second part of my reading began with the Laws of Variation. Mr. Darwin writes at some length about the reproductive system being subject to changes from the conditions of life, how deviation must have causes, and how elements of an organism can be lost through disuse. He cites many examples. He talks about plants in different climates. I am not entirely sure how to convey how interesting I find these sections, simply as a student of the world, but I kept feeling as if this book might do well to have illustrations. Lo and behold, such an edition exists and now my heart is full of discontent over my measly Bantam Classics mass market paperback. It would benefit from illustrations for those times when one is reading away from Google and Wikipedia and cannot look up the 550 species of beetles in Madeira or the opercular valves of sissile cirripedes.
While he readily admits our profound ignorance of the laws of variation, he, nonetheless, does illustrate to satisfaction that it is observable in nature that habit, use, and disuse have and do play an important role in the modification of organisms. He also, as seems to be his custom, then examines the issue through the lens of what humans are capable of with breeding and domestication. He points out that the tendency towards variation and the tendency to return to the original states both serve to make sustained traits difficult in breeding.
Returning once again to matters ecclesiastical, I was surprised to find this line at the end of a chapter, specifically referring to those who might argue for the independent creation of each individual species. He says that this argument "makes the works of God a mere mockery and deception; I would almost as soon believe with the old and ignorant cosmogonists, that fossil shells had never lived, but had been created in stone so as to mock the shells now living on the sea-shore." I was astonished at how similar this was to my own reasoning. I have had discussions before over stars and our knowledge of the Speed of Light alone suggesting that either 1) the Universe is ancient beyond our imagination or 2) God made the stars look old to trick us.
It might also be prudent to note at this point another common misunderstanding. Mr. Darwin is not writing about the Origin of Life. He is writing about the Origin of Species. As of writing this I am about 2/3rds of the way through the text and so far that is his entire focus in this book. It is a book suggesting that species evolve(d) from other species. It does not mention the point of singularity.
Another section which surprised me was his addressing of Difficulties on Theory. Have you ever heard any of these arguments against Darwinian Evolution?:
-If species evolved from other species, where are the transitional forms?
-Why are there seemingly trifling organs?
-How could an organ as complex as an eye evolve?
-What about the seeming intelligence of, for example, the bee and the cells which they create?
-What about sterility in crossed species?
I have heard all of these arguments from those who oppose the concept of Darwinian Evolution. I have heard those questions from pulpits and in Christian books. What I had not heard from those sources is that all of those questions are addressed and answered by Darwin in this book. This alone would, in my opinion, be sufficient reason to recommend reading this book to anyone. I do wonder if the reason these arguments are used by the opposition is from a lazy cursory reading of Darwin or simply feeling safe in the assumption that none of their readers will actually go and read Darwin for themselves. However, again, I feel I should state that belief or disbelief are moot. You can disbelieve gravitation all you want, but you're still not going to float off into space.
Also, I am not going to go over his responses here because you should read the book (and write your own paper.)
Darwin likens how certain variations emerge at certain times to how at certain points in time you will find two men coming up with the same invention completely independently of one another. Which is funny because that is precisely the case in the book that I am reading. Darwin hastened publication of this book because Alfred Russel Wallace had come up with the same idea on his own. Darwin wanted to beat him to the punch and so rushed to press.
Darwin begins employing a Latin phrase in this section as well which seems like it is to recur throughout the rest of my reading: Natura non facit saltum. It is the natural selection mantra. It means "Nature does not make jumps." We will return to this concept many times I'm sure.
I also read the section on Instinct. We spend a lot of time watching insects in this chapter. I was surprised by the existence of philanthropy in nature (as illustrated by the behavior of aphides towards ants.) Also about the existence of slaves in certain insect communities. He rounds out the chapter with a fascinating look at the structure of honeycombs.
Another surprise to me has been how readable I've found this book. I have not found it difficult in the least. So far St. Augustine has been the biggest slog in this series. I am finding Darwin if not overly charming at the very least quite interesting.
While he readily admits our profound ignorance of the laws of variation, he, nonetheless, does illustrate to satisfaction that it is observable in nature that habit, use, and disuse have and do play an important role in the modification of organisms. He also, as seems to be his custom, then examines the issue through the lens of what humans are capable of with breeding and domestication. He points out that the tendency towards variation and the tendency to return to the original states both serve to make sustained traits difficult in breeding.
Returning once again to matters ecclesiastical, I was surprised to find this line at the end of a chapter, specifically referring to those who might argue for the independent creation of each individual species. He says that this argument "makes the works of God a mere mockery and deception; I would almost as soon believe with the old and ignorant cosmogonists, that fossil shells had never lived, but had been created in stone so as to mock the shells now living on the sea-shore." I was astonished at how similar this was to my own reasoning. I have had discussions before over stars and our knowledge of the Speed of Light alone suggesting that either 1) the Universe is ancient beyond our imagination or 2) God made the stars look old to trick us.
It might also be prudent to note at this point another common misunderstanding. Mr. Darwin is not writing about the Origin of Life. He is writing about the Origin of Species. As of writing this I am about 2/3rds of the way through the text and so far that is his entire focus in this book. It is a book suggesting that species evolve(d) from other species. It does not mention the point of singularity.
Another section which surprised me was his addressing of Difficulties on Theory. Have you ever heard any of these arguments against Darwinian Evolution?:
-If species evolved from other species, where are the transitional forms?
-Why are there seemingly trifling organs?
-How could an organ as complex as an eye evolve?
-What about the seeming intelligence of, for example, the bee and the cells which they create?
-What about sterility in crossed species?
I have heard all of these arguments from those who oppose the concept of Darwinian Evolution. I have heard those questions from pulpits and in Christian books. What I had not heard from those sources is that all of those questions are addressed and answered by Darwin in this book. This alone would, in my opinion, be sufficient reason to recommend reading this book to anyone. I do wonder if the reason these arguments are used by the opposition is from a lazy cursory reading of Darwin or simply feeling safe in the assumption that none of their readers will actually go and read Darwin for themselves. However, again, I feel I should state that belief or disbelief are moot. You can disbelieve gravitation all you want, but you're still not going to float off into space.
Also, I am not going to go over his responses here because you should read the book (and write your own paper.)
Darwin likens how certain variations emerge at certain times to how at certain points in time you will find two men coming up with the same invention completely independently of one another. Which is funny because that is precisely the case in the book that I am reading. Darwin hastened publication of this book because Alfred Russel Wallace had come up with the same idea on his own. Darwin wanted to beat him to the punch and so rushed to press.
Darwin begins employing a Latin phrase in this section as well which seems like it is to recur throughout the rest of my reading: Natura non facit saltum. It is the natural selection mantra. It means "Nature does not make jumps." We will return to this concept many times I'm sure.
I also read the section on Instinct. We spend a lot of time watching insects in this chapter. I was surprised by the existence of philanthropy in nature (as illustrated by the behavior of aphides towards ants.) Also about the existence of slaves in certain insect communities. He rounds out the chapter with a fascinating look at the structure of honeycombs.
Another surprise to me has been how readable I've found this book. I have not found it difficult in the least. So far St. Augustine has been the biggest slog in this series. I am finding Darwin if not overly charming at the very least quite interesting.
Monday, May 28, 2012
Ask Paul Mathers- Vegan Gifts
Here's another installment of Ask Paul Mathers. If you have a question you would like Paul Mathers to answer in video form, send your question to: askpaulmathers@gmail.com
Here is a link to the book mentioned in the video.
Enjoy! And good luck!
Thursday, May 24, 2012
Charles Darwin's On The Origin of Species- Part 1
I have decided to cut my reactions to The Origin of Species into four sections as I am reading it. In hindsight, I ought to have done this with Wealth of Nations as well. I feel like 1/4th of this book will provide ample material to fill a blog post."I do not feel obliged to believe that the same God who has endowed us with sense, reason, and intellect has intended us to forgo their use."- Galileo Galilei
When I came to read this book, I half expected the central theme and thesis to be something along the lines of this:
"Peoples is monkeys and there ain't no God."That is because, since early in the history of this book, that is how a good portion of Western organized religion has characterized Mr. Darwin's work. I am given to understand that this included the former captain of HMS Beagle. Darwin, along with Copernicus and Freud, deals one of the Three Major Blows to the Human Ego. Its reception by certain types within religious circles has become a self-parody of the ostrich-like effects of insecure faith. And, there I go, tipping my hand as to what I think.
I have been more than a little astonished to find, in recent years, certain members of the scientainment community arguing Darwin as if the Christian mischaracterization were accurate. So, let me preface by saying that I am about to say some things that I know will make some group of people out there angry and/or feel the need to correct me.
I don't "believe" in Darwinian Evolution any more than I "believe" in plate tectonics. It simply is. I object to being called a "guided" evolutionist on the grounds that we don't feel the need to apply "guided" before "physics" or "gravitation." I am a Protestant Christian with deep and heavy roots in Quakerism. Therefore, I hold that there is a God, and that we humans, in our natural state, have a sin nature which separates us from Him. He, in His infinite goodness, became human, was willingly sacrificed to atone for our sins, rose from the dead, and will return, and that all who believe in Him will have eternal life with Him. This, to me, has nothing to do with what Mr. Darwin is writing about, save that we are able to better understand the workings and processes of the universe around us through the scientific method. What Mr. Darwin had to say seems to be an entirely reasonable presentation of the observable facts available at the time, and the information available after him seems to only further back up the concepts. I feel that people within my religion who fight so hard against this reveal some pretty hefty latent doubts. I feel that a hoard of charlatans and carpetbaggers have exploited this false dichotomy. There is an industry and people profit from it. I can't say whether or not profit is their primary motivation. Be that as it may, you can go into stores and spend money on things exploiting this false dichotomy. This occurs on both sides of the argument.
I have no desire to discuss why people think I am wrong about what I've just written. I am a little sad that I had to write all of that just to be able to talk about the ideas in the book that I'm reading. I should have liked to have interacted with the ideas presented here without the loads of baggage. But, don't let's set up camp there.
So far, this is largely a book about animal husbandry and gardening techniques. It mainly reads more like this:
The emminent naturalist, to whom I am indebted for having shown me countless sketches of various beak types, Dr. Geisel states that a certain variety of Sneetches in generally clement and fair littoral climate have manifested a pattern surrounding their navel in a distinct pentagram while others in the same locale have no such marking.(not an actual quote)
He will then explain why diet, climate, or some advantage has caused this change. He will also talk about similarities or differences in producing these effects in domestic varieties. This will go on for a page or two and then he will move on to some other bit of flora or fauna.
I wrote in the margins around the third chapter that, were this just slightly more pastoral, it would be exactly what I wished Thoreau was like when I was reading Walden. It's like talking to someone who has an encyclopedic knowledge of varieties of plants and animals. He lists why certain birds have certain kinds of beaks, certain plants have certain flowers, certain shells in certain places are brighter than others in other places. Let me put a fine point on this: This sort of thing is the bulk of what I've read in this book so far.
Of course, there are parts of this which argue against special creation, which is to say the idea that God created every variety of every plant and animal. At this point in history, it would take a very special kind of person to actually make that argument. We know that we made mules. We are so far beyond this concept now that we are actually creating new forms of life.
Some of the language is a bit archaic, although I feel that anyone with a successful high school level education would find the book within the grasp of their comprehension. There are portions where he talks about what he refers to as "monstrosities." Yes, he is talking about cleft palets and microcephaly and those sort of things. To my modern eyes, I found his liberal designation of disabilities as "monstrous" as, well, a bit monstrous. Like a good scientist, he defines his terms:
"By a monstrosity I presume is meant some considerable deviation of structure in one part, either injurious to or not useful to the species, and generally not propagated."I know that this is where some make the link to some of the more unfortunate ideologies of the early 20th century. I would hasten to point out that Mr. Darwin is not putting a philosophy forward. He is simply attempting to make objective observations about the available data.
Another area which pushes the envelope of my comfort zone is when he unabashedly admits to vivisection. In fact, so far, for me that's been the most morally problematic section of Darwin.
The main point so far seems to be inherited traits, peculiarities appearing in similar times and circumstances, our known, observable, and re-creatable capacity as humans to employ selection in agriculture (think dogs and splicing produce plants. Now think of dozens of pages of examples), observable instances of selection in nature without the guiding hand of man, examples from history (our hero Pliny once again makes an appearance to show that pears of antiquity were an inferior fruit, but have since been cultivated to one of the finer fruits), how diversity equals success (a concept which I am tempted to conflate into philosophy, but shall restrain myself in deference to our esteemed host), how the record of animals seems to focus almost exclusively on those animals which humans find useful in some way, how the struggle for life births variations which will tend towards survival (careful to note that this is not to be confused with willful selection, but rather an emergent outcome from conditions), and entropy as an essential. At the end of one chapter, he gets as close to optimism as we're going to get in this work when he writes:
"When we reflect on this struggle, we may console ourselves with the full belief, that the war of nature is not incessant, that no fear is felt, that death is generally prompt, and that the vigorous, the healthy, and the happy survive and multiply."From what I know of Mr. Darwin's life, he was not a man I would describe as vigorous, healthy, or particularly noted for his happiness.
I wonder if Dr. Eliot might have placed this work at this point in our series, just after Adam Smith, to further explore the concept of an "Invisible Hand" which guides certain observable processes. Our time is brief and nature's work is staggeringly long. However, the minutiae counts in ways we couldn't have imagined.
We are that minutiae.
More soon.
Saturday, May 19, 2012
New Clairvaux
Today we went to visit the Abbey of New Clairveaux in the town of Vina which is also the home of the New Clairvaux Vineyard. We had spoken to our friends Troy and Molly recently over how we've meant to visit the place for years, but had never gotten around to doing it. It is only around a half an hour's drive from our home. Last night, Troy called to invite us to join them as they visit the vineyard.
The Abbey of New Clairvaux is a Trappist or "Cistercian" monastery. Trappists, as you may know, are one of the monastic paths that focus on labor and efficiency. If you're like me, you have a smattering of knowledge on the subject from that time in your 20s when you read Thomas Merton and thought you might like to become a monk (but not seriously.) One of the most influential early Cistercians was Bernard of Clairvaux (for fellow church history buffs, you will remember his famous debate with Abelard.)
New Clairvaux was, in fact, established in the 1950s when the Abbey of Gethsemani in Kentucky grew too large. They sent a group out to California to start a spin-off. Yes, not spoken in any of the history material I found at New Clairvaux, but easy to piece together, the Abbey of Gethsemani was the very monastery where Thomas Merton abode. And, yes, he was there and world-famous in the 1950s. So, this monastery could well exist because of that very impulse I cited earlier, but rather for those who did take that thought seriously when they read Thomas Merton in their 20s.
First, we got right down to business and visited the tasting room. We tried the St. James Albariño from 2011 (a lovely white wine which we very nearly bought), the 2010 Poor Souls Barbera (which we did buy), the 2009 St. James Syrah (not our favorite), and the 2007 Abbot's Reserve (quite possibly the best wine I have ever tasted.)
Had I a psychic connection with Laurie and known that she would have agreed that we should flagrantly flaunt our budget restrictions and buy it at any price, we would have a bottle of the Abbot's Reserve in our wine rack right now. We console ourselves with the knowledge that this was not "our trip to the New Clairvaux Vineyard" but rather "our first trip to the New Clairvaux Vineyard."
All around the campus there were these gorgeous spots that seemed like time had come unhinged. One kept glimpsing the modern right next to the antique right next to the ancient.
Which brings us to the rebuilding of the Santa María de Óvila Chapter House.
The building was originally a building in Guadalajara circa somewhere around 1190. In the mid-1800s the Spanish government confiscated the property and disassembled it. Almost 100 years later, William Randolph Hearst bought the stones, intending to use it to build some castle for himself somewhere that he never got around to. They sat in a warehouse in San Francisco until the monks of New Clairvaux purchased them to rebuild the Chapter House on their Vina property.
Standing in the building, in the midst of construction, I felt both the weight and insignificance of eternity, as if I were enveloped in something at once much older than I and, in spite of appearances, fragile.
Their website shows what they are planning for the completion of the project.
After the vineyard, we had a picnic at the Woodson Bridge park and played Kubb in the grass by the banks of the Sacramento River. It was one of the more splendid Saturdays we've had in recent memory.
The Abbey of New Clairvaux is a Trappist or "Cistercian" monastery. Trappists, as you may know, are one of the monastic paths that focus on labor and efficiency. If you're like me, you have a smattering of knowledge on the subject from that time in your 20s when you read Thomas Merton and thought you might like to become a monk (but not seriously.) One of the most influential early Cistercians was Bernard of Clairvaux (for fellow church history buffs, you will remember his famous debate with Abelard.)
New Clairvaux was, in fact, established in the 1950s when the Abbey of Gethsemani in Kentucky grew too large. They sent a group out to California to start a spin-off. Yes, not spoken in any of the history material I found at New Clairvaux, but easy to piece together, the Abbey of Gethsemani was the very monastery where Thomas Merton abode. And, yes, he was there and world-famous in the 1950s. So, this monastery could well exist because of that very impulse I cited earlier, but rather for those who did take that thought seriously when they read Thomas Merton in their 20s.
First, we got right down to business and visited the tasting room. We tried the St. James Albariño from 2011 (a lovely white wine which we very nearly bought), the 2010 Poor Souls Barbera (which we did buy), the 2009 St. James Syrah (not our favorite), and the 2007 Abbot's Reserve (quite possibly the best wine I have ever tasted.)
Had I a psychic connection with Laurie and known that she would have agreed that we should flagrantly flaunt our budget restrictions and buy it at any price, we would have a bottle of the Abbot's Reserve in our wine rack right now. We console ourselves with the knowledge that this was not "our trip to the New Clairvaux Vineyard" but rather "our first trip to the New Clairvaux Vineyard."
All around the campus there were these gorgeous spots that seemed like time had come unhinged. One kept glimpsing the modern right next to the antique right next to the ancient.
Which brings us to the rebuilding of the Santa María de Óvila Chapter House.
Standing in the building, in the midst of construction, I felt both the weight and insignificance of eternity, as if I were enveloped in something at once much older than I and, in spite of appearances, fragile.
Their website shows what they are planning for the completion of the project.
After the vineyard, we had a picnic at the Woodson Bridge park and played Kubb in the grass by the banks of the Sacramento River. It was one of the more splendid Saturdays we've had in recent memory.
Saturday, May 12, 2012
My Laocoön: Alternative Claims in the Interpretation of Artworks by Richard Brilliant
"[A] well known piece of baseball philosophy. Three umpires are discussing how they do their jobs. The first, who is also the least experienced, says, "I call 'em as they are." The second, who has been in the game a little longer, says, "I call 'em as I see 'em." The third says, "They're nothing till I call 'em." These three could be characterized as objectivism, relativism, and postmodernism respectively." -Andrew Rawlinson
The above quote is simultaneously the epigraph placed at the beginning of the final section of My Laocoön: Alternative Claims in the Interpretation of Artworks by Richard Brilliant, as well as the first and last time you will see a sports metaphor on my blog. Be that as it may, it sums up Professor Brilliant's thesis nicely. My Laocoön is, in one sense, a book about the famous masterpiece known as Laocoön and His Sons or the Laocoön Group which resides in the Vatican. Pliny the Elder attributes the piece to three sculptors from Rhodes. You are most likely familiar with some variation of the image. It looks like this:
But it also looks like this:
There is a rich and complex history of the images which, if memory serves, Professor Brilliant finally totals about 4 different versions. The first is the Book of Q version which is the original which we shall never see. The second is the image immediately above, if I've followed the labyrinthine narrative properly, discovered in 1506 and highly influential on Renaissance artists. The last is the restoration of the 1950s (the first of the two I've posted above) which is considered more "correct."
Professor Brilliant also speaks of a third image which is extracted from the 1506 version, but achieves an "otherness" even to the point of requiring another category as the image becomes "a vehicle for critical discourse on the nature of art and its powers." A portion of the text deals with specific critical responses. There is also a moment, early in the work, where Professor Brilliant tells about a time when he sat by the two sculptures in the Cortile del Belvedere (which people pass through on their way to the Sistine Chapel) and watched the tourists pass by, observing their responses. A good deal of them were confused by two similar statues placed side by side. Some knew the history of sculpture and knew to some extent that the less authentic is still largely the authoritative version in our culture which has weaved so much time, thought, and history into the 1506 version.
Professor Brilliant writes, "Yet, rarely did they appear to engage the sculpture as a work of art having meaning for them as an aesthetic object of value."
I felt that, at this moment, he reveals a sort of superobjective, an unspoken thesis. By no means is this an anti-intellectualism argument. I do know art, and I like what I know. Notwithstanding, there is a danger of opacity on either end of the spectrum: be it through ignorance and apathy, or be it through seeing the image so much through the filter of what others have written/thought about it that one cannot see the image for itself. Indeed, the book is also, in fact I would dare suggest primarily, about ways of seeing art, using a piece with a history of interpretation and reproduction variants wrapping around the piece like so many snakes.
He also compares the ways of seeing the Laocoön with other masterpieces that have suffered similar contortionistic manipulations. He mentions Titian's Sacred and Profane Love:
Which is likely not even the original title or subject matter. He spends a portion of the book talking about titles, both important as reference points and misleading. For example, he also talks of Picasso's Les Demoiselles d'Avignon. Picasso himself was reluctant (petulant even) to name his paintings.
He also brings up Velasquez's Las Meninas (I have a reproduction of it in my living room.) The enigmatic presentation of the image has inspired volume upon speculative volume on the piece:
I cannot speak for Professor Brilliant, although I thoroughly enjoyed the ameliorating experience provided by way of his work. I have my suspicions that he would agree with a metaphor of my own devising on the matter. There is little in this life so enriching as to be excited about art. The arts reflect the highest aspirations of humankind. To seek to know more is a natural outworking of said excitement. Looking to what's been observed about a work is a bit like spicing a dish. Properly measured, it can make the entire experience much richer than it ever could be on its own. Poorly measured, it can drown all of the inherent flavor of the dish. I'm not sure if it was his intention to put so fine a point of this danger, however I find it was my primary takeaway from the book.
Sunday, May 6, 2012
Infinite Riches in a Little Room
Every year, I have 12 inter-library loans allotted to me by the Butte County Library. I do my best not to waste a single one. The inter-library loan system is as follows: if you go to your library and ask for a book and they do not have it in the building, there are people whose job is to track down a copy at another library and then convince that library to loan it to you through their library. You, the patron, have only to fill out a chit of paper with the book title and your name and contact information. Then you go home and, usually, in my experience, after you've forgotten that any of this went on, you get a call saying your book is there.
The time limit is up to the discretion of the lending library. I was told this time that my book came all the way from Humboldt and that they were one of the stricter libraries in regards to the amount of time they allowed their books to disperse into the hands of the public. In this case, I think I have about a week with the book.
On the few occasions where necessity has lead me to thin my personal library either for moving purposes or lack of space (a process which is like deciding which of your fingers to cut off) I tend to look first to the books that would be easily accessible in any library. Looking directly over the top of my laptop as I write this, I can see two copies of Jane Eyre on my shelf. In the circumstance of a book thinning, at least one of those would probably go. I also should state that I have no intention of thinning out my personal library again so long as I live if I can help it. Be that as it may, there are other types of books which are not readily available at any library.
I love the Chico Library, but... Well, to put it nicely, if I had a disposable income, I would donate liberally to the Chico Library in hopes that they could improve the sphere of their offerings. Nonetheless, if I suspend my demand for instant gratification and put in an inter-library loan request when (inevitably) I want to read a book that they don't have on-hand, they can get me that book!
In this case it was My Laocoön: Alternative Claims in the Interpretation of Artworks by Richard Brilliant. Cost prohibitive left to my own means and not a title one finds in every library, but something I desperately wanted to read as soon as I heard of it. More on it in a few days when I've finished it.
The clock is ticking. The beautiful thing about your local lending library is that they are strengthened by use. We've recently had a little struggle in Chico where the city severely cut the hours of the library, but were forced to reconsider when reports confirmed how important and valuable the library is to the community. Also, it confirmed what a great job they do. I encourage everyone to exercise all of the uses of their local library. It is a place where heaps of information are there for the taking, totally at your disposal. It frightens and disturbs me that they are not more widely used. As the line from Auntie Mame so famously puts it, "Life's a banquet and most poor suckers are starving to death!" Libraries are, in my opinion, one of the greatest concepts humankind as come up with.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)





















